Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Of Chetan Bhagat and unlimited parking in our brain

There’s a scene in Wake Up Sid where the editor of a magazine (Rahul Khanna) smiles mockingly, almost in disbelief when his colleague (Konkona) tells him that she does not enjoy jazz music.

Mujhe purane Hindi filmon ke gaane pasand hain,” she says. “Unko gaa toh sakte hain.” (I like Hindi film songs...the classics. Atleast one can hum them.)

For me, this scene was one of the high points of the film. The argument was spot on and I wanted to congratulate the film’s scriptwriter for penning this scene. Here's why.

For long, I’ve been amazed at how journalists, especially senior editors, editors, literary critics or Sunday edition reporters have consistently mocked popular choices in entertainment.

If you like jazz, you’re cool. If you like Singh is King, you’re uncool. If you’re a fan of Coetzee, you’ve arrived. If you’re reading Chetan Bhagat, you don’t have any taste in literature. And your sense of humor is down in the dumps if you’ve laughed your ass off in 3 Idiots.

Generalisations like these have often baffled me. Are you trying to suggest that your tastes are superior to mine? I've seen 3 Idiots in two cities - Mumbai and Kolkata - and I've never seen housefull auditoriums laugh their ass off like they did while watching this film. And then I've met some - all in the journalist/media fraternity, who can't seem to make out what's so great about a film. I think I'll send them a DVD of The Blairwitch Project.

In November, I remember, Indian Twitterati, friends in the media drummed up hot air (mostly negative) about how Chetan Bhagat’s books do not deserve to be read, what a terrible author he is, etc. I was hysterical when I heard about this, since I've seen from close quarters how students, first time novel readers have pored over Chetan Bhagat novels in the most crowded trains. I travelled to Kolkata recently by train and in my compartment, out of the roughly 7-8 people reading book during the journey, 5 of them were absorbed in Chetan Bhagat novels. That’s quite an achievement. And then they say that the bugger can’t write.

I was at a day-long conference recently where Bhagat was part of a panel discussion and despite his Delhi-ised English accent, he made absolute sense in every word he said. But to many in the audience, most of whom seemed to be the 'discerning snob' types, he remained the butt of all jokes. Even during the networking lunch, very few walked up to him to greet him. The best-selling Indian author was not hounded, like he is when is amongst his fans.

I’ve come to recognise these people as the ‘new age snobs’. They’ll consume Kurosawa, Wong Kar Wai, Truffaut films and appear like they’ve seen the world and they’ll conveniently skip the biggest blockbusters from the country – Ghajini, 3 Idiots, Om Shanti Om, Singh is King – dismissing them as utter crap / entertainment for the masses. They won’t travel by train – they might as well describe it as cattle class. My best friend is a film critic and I admire him not because he bowled me over with his understanding of world cinema, but also because of his maturity at accepting popular cinema targeted at the masses.

What worries me is that most media houses are run by the 'snobs'. And they always have been. When you’re running a newspaper for an audience that comprises the masses, how can you have such different tastes than them? This is why typically film critics’reviews and audience reactions vary to a great degree.

Does that mean that we must encourage people like Taran Adarsh (who are trade experts and not film-critics per se) to review films for us? I’m not so sure. It’s a very debatable topic, particularly because of his trade background. But I think over time we need art and literature critics who are good at recommending the most deserving choices to their audiences. Rather than those, who aiming to send their CVs to The New Yorker.

I think the ideal consumption of literature is one that includes the good, bad and the ugly. So read all you can gather on a platter. Read the masterpieces, the classics, read the chick lits, read the thrillers. Also read the Mills & Boon and Nicholas Sparks. A Titan commercial quotes Aamir Khan saying, “Be born everyday. Aaj rockstar, kal pilot. Kabhi kisi anjaan station pe utar ke dekho. Kabhi kisi gumnaam sheher ka ticket katao...Be more.”

Ratatouille, the delightful animation movie about the adventures of a rat who wants to cook, also elucidates the same point wherein the food critic, Ego, admits as to how literary critics often forget to appreciate the simple things. Like a plate of ratatouille.

Absolutely true.

If you’re going to confine yourself to only certain kind of authors, certain kinds of films, then you’re a one-way street, with no parking.

Our mind is best conditioned as a two-way street, with unlimited parking.


Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Daniel D'Mello said...

"Are you trying to suggest that your tastes are superior to mine?"


What's popular is not necessarily better. A billion Indians reading Chetan Bhagat does not make him a good author. It makes him a well read one, which doesn't say much about the masses.

Sourav Roy said...

There are people who only consume certain kind of things to appear cultured and there are people who have consumed everything, their tastes have evolved, have become selective and ARE cultured. You must learn to separate the wheat from the chaff. And just like popularity is not a proof of quality, obscurity is not either. Reverse snobbery is as bad as snobbery, if not worse.

Arcopol Chaudhuri said...

@sourav Agree with you and I'm supportive of those who do read and see everything and then arrive at an opinion. That is how they can separate the wheat from the chaff.

amaresh gautam said...

i think you have got your logic completely reverse.

See it was 10 years ago that people were not exposed to good cinema from the west or rest of the world. I remember when i was young and thought that kuch kuch hota hain was absolute magic. Now thanks primarlily to the internet and LAN network of IIT kgp i have been exposed to kubrick , hitchcock and woody allen. Am i really being snobbish if i think karan johar is a crap movie maker.
watching more cinema makes me hate bollywood masala more , not less

Not all bollywood movies are bad.I crave for a good hindi movie as i would always relate to indian themes and characters more. But you can count good bollywood movies on your fingers. Last year there were three dev d , 3 idiots and kaminey which i enjoyed.

i wrote two blogs on chetan bhagat and popular choice. I have a sense you would have strong views on both of them

Anonymous said...


can anyone tell me which is the best counter strike guide ? :)...i found this one :

What do you about beside it ?

Thanx in advance

Sorry for my bad english :s

Anonymous said...


When ever I surf on web I come to this website[url=].[/url]You have really contiributed very good info here Do you pay attention towards your health?. Here is a fact for you. Recent Scientific Research indicates that about 80% of all USA grownups are either obese or weighty[url=].[/url] Hence if you're one of these individuals, you're not alone. In fact, most of us need to lose a few pounds once in a while to get sexy and perfect six pack abs. Now the question is how you are planning to have quick weight loss? You can easily lose with with little effort. You need to improve some of you daily habbits to achive weight loss in short span of time.

About me: I am writer of [url=]Quick weight loss tips[/url]. I am also mentor who can help you lose weight quickly. If you do not want to go under difficult training program than you may also try [url=]Acai Berry[/url] or [url=]Colon Cleansing[/url] for quick weight loss.

Sourav Roy said...

Anonymous wants you to lose weight. If that's not funny, dunno what is. :-D

Anonymous said...

Correctly your article helped me altogether much in my college assignment. Hats off to you dispatch, will look forward in the direction of more cognate articles in a jiffy as its united of my pick topic to read.

Chandni said...

Aha, I have had similar views about Chetan Bhagat and have attracted flak from friends and foes alike. I don't understand why you can't read a Bhagat 'blockbuster' and a Dickens int he same go. Why does there hae to be a clash of tastes?

Meher....all out to explore..!! said...

Majorly true.But i'll disagree with the Bhagat part.Yes,he makes sense when he speaks.And I've had the privelege(Not!) of reading all his books.And I haven't enjoyed them.
But yes,we need to appreciate our cimemas too for their massy appeal.Everybody ain't a tarantino.

Anonymous said...

Genial fill someone in on and this fill someone in on helped me alot in my college assignement. Gratefulness you as your information.

Anonymous said...

Its awesome all of the time to view how folks can compose wonderful stuff about people topics! Thank you and I ve bookmarked you